(third in a series)

As the Moon circles the Earth and both bodies make their way around the sun, we’d like to maintain near-constant communication between astronauts and their home planet. During Apollo, astronaut landings were restricted to the lunar near-side, in direct line-of-sight radio communication with Earth. Back then, the command module pilot would be out of touch for half of every orbit—an hour–as he circled the lunar farside. One way around that outage is a large, looping orbit called a near-rectilinear halo orbit (NRHO). That orbit has some favorable characteristics at the Moon. Its orbital plane around the Moon is nearly perpendicular to a line from Earth, and rarely carries a craft behind the Moon, so direct communications are nearly always possible. (Putting comm relay satellites in lunar orbit could also eliminate blockages and their communication problems.)

The NRHO is a big, loopy orbit, with an orbital period of about a week. At perilune the orbit is very close to the moon, while most of the orbit out to apolune and back gives one an excellent view of the moon and the distant Earth. From the halo orbit, we can with very little rocket energy drop down to an orbit favorable for landing, or just as easily rocket back to Earth.
The NRHO contrasts with Apollo’s low, equatorial orbit. Apollo orbited only about 60 miles above the moon, circling once every 2 hours. But that orbit severely limited where the Apollo spacecraft could take its astronauts, and it was quickly perturbed by the moon’s lumpy gravity field. The NRHO offers a well-behaved orbit that allows good communications back to Earth and is in sunshine nearly all the time (for power generation). It won’t carry us behind the moon and cut us off for long periods. And the orbit gives us access to orbits to access the surface at nearly any time and to nearly any place on the moon that we would like to go, not limited to sites near the equatorial plane at which the Apollo missions were targeted.

However, the NRHO has some drawbacks. An Artemis lander must use fuel to maneuver into a near-rectilinear halo orbit to meet Orion, and then use still more fuel to drop into a lower orbit for approach to landing. Further, a lander aborting from the Moon’s surface in an emergency might take as long as three and a half days to reach an Orion waiting in the NRHO. Unfortunately, Orion’s propulsion system, housed in its European-built service module, doesn’t have enough fuel to drop the spacecraft into a low lunar orbit to rescue a crew. Due to lift limitations of the SLS booster, Orion has just enough propellant to break out of its NRHO when it’s time for an Earth return. The pros and cons of an NRHO vs. a different, lower lunar orbit are worth further examination.
Nevertheless, reason number one for going back to the moon is that it’s accessible, and we should take advantage of that attribute, no matter what orbit we finally choose.
Next: The Moon is Interesting


Another excellent article, Tom. I especially appreciate the pro and cons regarding NRHO. But please don’t give SLS performance all the blame for the Service Module’s (SM’s) capability shortfall. That capability was by design to minimize scaling ESA’s now-retired Automated Transfer Vehicle (ATV), which served as the SM’s baseline. Since ATV served as an ISS cargo vehicle, it’s no wonder the SM is challenged to get Orion in and out of any but the most high-altitude of lunar orbits, let alone perform a Human Landing System rescue. Even Block I SLS can send more mass toward the Moon than Orion, which is why secondary payloads are manifested on both Artemis I and II.
It should also be noted the Artemis NRHO’s high altitudes near 70,000 km make it unstable due to Earth (and, to a lesser extent, Sun) gravity perturbations near apocynthion. Operationally, this instability could be more challenging to manage than the 100 km orbit heights flown by Apollo spacecraft.
Thanks as always for your thoughtful additions and illumination, Dan. The Service Module carries a refurbished shuttle Orbital Maneuvering System engine (OMS) as its main engine, but without the propellant needed, it’s limited in performance. I think the Apollo SPS engine was rated at 20,000 pounds of thrust–OMS is 6000. Perhaps ESA can stretch those propellant tanks on future SMs.