I enjoyed audience questions after my recent “Back to the Moon” talk. Here is a sampling:
Question: Why don’t we skip the lifeless Moon and go on to Mars, where the real question of “life on other worlds” beckons?
Tom answers: When President Obama canceled the return to the moon “Constellation” program in 2010, the Congress worried that if the bypassed the moon, the Chinese Communist Party would seize that low-hanging fruit–its resources and strategic position in Earth-Moon space. Much more quickly than we could reach Mars with humans, China would be doing exciting science and operations on another world. Even if we reached Mars around 2045 (a stretch), the CCP lunar presence would mean a real change in the global perception of which nation has the technological edge in the 21st Century. I think that’s why the Congress refocused NASA on returning to the Moon as a stepping stone on the way to Mars.
I don’t guess the Chinese are going to stop at the Moon. China’s CCP looks at history through a 500-year-long lens. They see that in about 1500 they were at the top of the world, with better ships than Vasco da Gama or Columbus. But their empire gave up on that, and of course, for the next 500 years they became a technological and economic backwater. That’s not the case today, and I would say that they are determined to write their own history in this millennium. They’ll duplicate Apollo at first, but they want to then be the first nation on Mars, too.
The practical effect of China being preeminent on the Moon is that the CCP may consider lunar resources as part of China’s “exclusive economic zone,” just as is their ambition in the South China Sea. The Chinese Communist Party could deny access. If we desire a Western economic and legal system on the Moon, where our international community can share those resources, and our economy can expand to the Moon and beyond, then we had better have a presence on the Moon.
We should of course continue the robotic exploration of Mars and our search for life there, but it’s important in my view to secure for humanity the open access to the Moon and the nearby asteroids—and their valuable resources—as the foundation for our eventual human expeditions to Mars.
(Image: Scientist Long Lehao unveils China manned lunar landing plan. via Global Times)



Leave a Reply